How Many Nonfatal Shootings End In An Arrest?

Highlights

Per the examples below, the vast majority of nonfatal shootings do not end in an arrest.

It will take money, technology, public support, and a considerable influx of highly trained investigators with reasonable caseloads to improve outcomes.

Author

Quotes

All quotes are edited for brevity.

Definition of Cleared Shootings

A crime is cleared when an arrest is made or law enforcement has evidence as to who the offender is but, for a multitude of reasons, a suspect is not arrested. I also use the terms “solved or unsolved” shootings in the article.

Article

The nation is riveted on mass shootings (most of which are street-level crimes where the shooter knows the victims) and criminal homicides. But what about shootings that don’t fall into either category? We assume that if someone shoots and is not apprehended, he will shoot again.

The idea for the article was submitted by Chris Hertig, a retired professor from York College, PA. He forwarded the article below on unsolved shootings in Harrisburg, PA.

The number of shootings that don’t result in homicides in Chicago and other big cities is almost legendary. We’ve all read the articles on holiday shootings with scores of victims. The question is how many of these events were cleared.

I reviewed articles on “how many shootings end in arrest” and “nonfatal shootings.” There were few references to nonfatal shootings. There were endless references to mass shootings, police shootings, and homicides, but little on everyday nonfatal shootings.

Surprisingly, there is little from government as to this issue. Most references in this article are media based.

Homicides-Half Are Arrested

We know that only half of homicides end in arrest. The Marshall Project examined a variety of police agencies in America as to the percentage of homicides where someone was charged and the results for some jurisdictions are dismal.

Homicide clearance rates have dramatic ranges, from 100 percent in Camden, NJ to areas with less than 20 percent cleared. Some jurisdictions clear most of their homicides. Many do not. The number of homicides seems to play a role in how many are cleared but that differs from jurisdiction to jurisdiction.

Homicides Victims And Suspects

In Washington, D.C., approximately 86 percent of homicide victims and suspects were known to the criminal justice system prior to the incident. Among all victims and suspects, about 46 percent had been previously incarcerated.

I assume that this dynamic also applies to nonfatal shootings in additional cities.

The Trace And BuzzFeed News-Unsolved Nonfatal Shootings

A yearlong investigation by The Trace and BuzzFeed News, based on data obtained from 22 cities, has found that:

In cities from coast to coast, the odds that police will solve a shooting are abysmally low and dropping. Homicides and assaults carried out with guns lead to arrests about half as often as when the same crimes are committed using other weapons or physical force.

The odds of an arrest are particularly low when victims survive (emphasis added), in part because those crimes tend to be assigned to detectives whose caseloads are exponentially higher compared to their colleagues in the homicide department, who are often overburdened themselves.

The chances are even lower if the victims, like Little, are people of color. When a black or Hispanic person is fatally shot, the likelihood that local detectives will catch the culprit is 35% — 18 percentage points fewer than when the victim is white. For gun assaults, the arrest rate is 21% if the victim is black or Hispanic, versus 37% for white victims.

By failing to solve so many shootings, police are “missing a potential opportunity to stop cascades of gun violence,” said Andrew Papachristos, a professor of sociology at Northwestern University.

Over the past three decades, the percentage of shooters who escape justice has soared.

The crisis of unsolved shootings isn’t confined to cash-strapped cities like Baltimore, but also hits some of America’s most affluent metropolises. In 2016, Los Angeles made arrests for just 17% of gun assaults, and Chicago for less than 12%. The same year, San Francisco managed to make arrests in just 15% of the city’s nonfatal shootings. In Boston, the figure was just 10%.

Unsolved Nonfatal Shootings-More Examples

Minneapolis

For now, someone has gotten away with a shooting, which happens in the vast majority of cases — nearly eight out of 10. About 78% of the 879 shootings in Minneapolis between 2018 and 2020 haven’t resulted in any arrests or charges, according to a Reformer analysis of police department records. And just because there’s an arrest or charge in a case, doesn’t mean it’s solved.

90% Of Harrisburg Shooters Don’t Get Arrested–Penn Live.Com

Kierston Miller and her 8-year-old cousin were in their kitchen in October when a bullet ripped through the screen door in Hall Manor hitting her in the bicep and the girl in her arm.  The stray bullet, likely fired in a dispute in a community park nearby, could have killed them. Eight months later, the case remains unsolved, like most nonfatal shootings in the city.

In fact, city police only solve about 10 percent of such shootings, leaving 90 percent of shooters on the streets to possibly strike again.

Police have made arrests or cleared 11 out of this year’s 13 homicides for a 85-percent clearance rate. But the rate remains shockingly low for non-fatal shootings because police say they get much less cooperation when victims survive. Namely, police say: witnesses are afraid of retaliation and being labeled a “snitch.”

Harrisburg isn’t alone in solving so few nonfatal shootings. Many cities across the country also log low solve rates, but there isn’t good data kept on these crimes.

Police records management systems do not typically include a specific focus on nonfatal shootings, according to a 2019 study by the U.S. Department of Justice. Although homicides are available in police records management systems, nonfatal shootings are often counted under other crime categories, particularly aggravated assaults and robberies. That means aggravated assaults and robberies involving a nonfatal shooting cannot be easily distinguished from other incidents where no one was actually shot.

The Manhattan Institute study mirrored Harrisburg police’s reasoning for the city’s low non-fatal clearance rate — lack of witnesses, as well as little to no forensic evidence. The report suggested police departments could be more successful at solving non-fatal shootings just by investigating with the intensity of a homicide investigation, and infusing additional resources into non-fatal cases.

However, investing additional resources is easier said than done in police departments already battered by the COVID-19 pandemic, forced to take on more investigatory work with fewer people.

Kansas City-500 Plus People Shot

According to Kansas City Police Department crime data, the city has recorded 79 homicides this year compared to 78 by this time in 2021. The statistics show Kansas City had a total of 157 homicides in 2021, the second highest in city history behind the 179 homicides that occurred in 2020.

Mayor Lucas said he believes two things are at the root of his city’s gun violence problem: Easy access to firearms and people in the community using them “with impunity.”

“It’s a troubling thing in our society when it’s easier to get a gun, particularly an assault weapon, rather than getting a therapist,” Lucas told WMBC. “This is something that is facing my community literally every day. We report the homicides, but there are roughly 500-plus people shot in Kansas City each year.”

Chicago

Only one person has been charged in any of the at least 39 mass shootings so far this year, according to a Sun-Times analysis of city data and court records.

That amounts to charges in just 2% of this year’s mass shootings — far below the police department’s dismal 13% clearance rate for shootings overall, which is the lowest of any big city in the nation.

Philadelphia

Mouhamed Cisse’s murder is one of more than 230 gun homicides this year that remains unsolved. Police have solved fewer than 30% of gun homicides in 2020.

The clearance rate is even worse when looking at non-fatal shootings, or those in which the victim survives. Only 16% of the 1,300 non-fatal shootings this year have been cleared.

Conclusions

Most violent crime categories do not end in an arrest or a “clearance” (see Statista and Pew ) and half of all homicides are cleared.  It’s apparent that clearance rates for nonfatal shootings lag behind arrests for murders for the examples above.

But based on the data on cleared homicides from The Marshall Project, (above) it’s impossible to empirically suggest that most nonfatal shootings are not cleared nationally. I’m unaware of any recent definitive government research on the topic. If homicide clearance rates can range between two and 100 percent, it’s possible (but highly unlikely) that the same dynamics apply to nonfatal shootings.

According to BradyUnited.Org, Every day, 321 people are shot (including suicides and accidents) in the United States. Among those:

• 111 people are shot and killed
• 210 survive gunshot injuries
• 95 are intentionally shot by someone else and survive
• 42 are murdered
• 1 is killed unintentionally
• 90 are shot unintentionally and survive
• 4 are shot by legal intervention and survive
• 1 died but the intent was unknown
• 12 are shot and survive but the intent was unknown

Via National Public Radio, in a new study published in the Annals of Internal Medicine, Dr. Zirui Song and colleagues found a four-fold increase in health care spending as a direct result of a non-fatal firearm injury. Fatal and nonfatal violence costs our nation $557 billion annually.

It’s clear that reported violent crime is increasing. Fear of crime is at record levels. Accountability for criminal offenders is rapidly diminishing with record lows for all arrests. Correctional numbers are at historic lows.

14,000 police officers have left their jobs in recent years and thousands more are in the process of leaving. The data on recruitment is dismal. Having sufficient experienced personnel to investigate shootings is rapidly diminishing. Cops no longer trust the American public.

Data suggests that it’s low-income, urban, often African American populations that are being hit the hardest.

The recent riots and protests seem to be the spark that has led us to rapidly increasing violence. Violence is changing our society with businesses leaving and economies eroding.

But the lack of accountability when it comes to shootings is an indicator of things to come. Violence is destroying cities. All violent crime is deeply concerning but unsolved shootings are completely unacceptable and destructive to our society. It will take money, technology, public support, and a considerable influx of highly trained investigators with reasonable caseloads to improve outcomes.

See More